© Reuters. FILE PHOTO: The gas compression terminal, part of the Polish section of the Yamal pipeline linking Russia with western Europe, is owned by a joint venture between Gazprom and BGNIG but operated by Polish state-owned gas transporter Gas -sis.
Written by Kate Abnett
BRUSSELS (Reuters) – European Union energy ministers agreed on Monday on a gas price cap after weeks of talks on the emergency measure, which has divided opinion among European Union states as it seeks to calm an energy crisis.
The cap is the latest attempt by the 27-nation European Union to lower gas prices, which have pushed up energy bills and pushed inflation to a record high this year after Russia cut off most gas shipments to Europe.
Ministers agreed to set a cap if prices exceed 180 euros ($191.11) per megawatt-hour for three days in the Dutch Gas Transfer Center (TTF) first-month contract, which serves as the European standard.
The TTF price should also be €35/MWh higher than the reference price based on current three-day LNG price assessments.
“We have succeeded in reaching an important agreement that protects citizens from skyrocketing energy prices,” said Josef Sekela, Minister of Industry of the Czech Republic, which holds the rotating presidency of the European Union.
The cap can start from February 15, 2023. The deal will be formally approved by the states in writing, after which it can enter into force.
Once operational, trades will not be permitted in first-month, three-month and first-year TTF contracts at a price more than €35/MWh above the LNG reference price.
This effectively sets the price at which gas can be traded, while allowing the maximum level to fluctuate in tandem with global LNG prices – a system designed to ensure EU countries can continue to bid competitively for gas from global markets.
Germany voted to back the deal, despite raising concerns about the impact of the policy on Europe’s ability to attract gas supplies on competitively priced global markets, three EU officials said.
An EU official told Reuters that Germany agreed to the price cap after countries agreed to changes to another regulation on accelerating permits for renewable energy, and stronger safeguards were added to the cap.
These safeguards include suspending the cap if the EU encounters a gas supply shortage, or if the cap causes a drop in fund trading, a jump in gas utilization, or a significant increase in margin calls for gas market participants.
Soaring energy and gas prices have rattled energy companies across Europe, forcing utilities and traders to secure additional money from governments and banks to cover margin call requirements.
German company Uniper incurred billions of euros in losses in derivatives, exacerbating the crisis as it scrambled to fill the remaining gap after Russia cut supplies.
The front month TTF contract rarely closes above €180/MWh, said Jacob Mandel, senior fellow at Aurora Energy Research, noting that this has happened in 64 days in its history. All of those were in the year 2022.
Debate months and meeting weeks
Two EU officials said that only Hungary had voted against capping prices.
The Netherlands and Austria abstained. Both resisted capping off during the negotiations, fearing it would disrupt Europe’s energy markets and jeopardize Europe’s energy security.
“Despite the progress made in the past two weeks, the market correction mechanism remains likely to be unsafe,” said Dutch Energy Minister Rob Gettin.
“I remain concerned about the major turmoil in the European energy market, about the financial implications, and most of all, I worry about the security of European supplies,” he added.
The EU proposal also met with opposition from some market participants, who said it could cause financial instability.
The Intercontinental Stock Exchange (NYSE: ), which hosts TTF trading on the Amsterdam Stock Exchange, said last week that it may move TTF trading out of the European Union if the bloc limits prices.
On Monday, it said it would assess whether it could continue to operate in fair and orderly markets for the TTF gas center trade. For now, the ICE TTF markets will continue to trade as normal.
Refinitiv Eikon data showed that the first-month gas price TTF closed trading Monday down 9%, at €107/MWh.
The contract reached a record high of €343 in August – a price hike that prompted the EU to push ahead with capping its price.
Its chairman, Stefano Pesegini, said on Monday that Italy’s energy authority expects further increases in gas prices as winter begins.
Meanwhile, Russian Kremlin spokesman Dmitry Peskov said the cap is an attack on market prices, and is unacceptable, Russia’s Interfax news agency reported.
The deal comes after months of wrangling over the idea and two previous emergency meetings that failed to reach agreement among EU countries that disagreed over whether the price cap would help or hinder Europe’s attempts to contain the energy crisis.
Nearly 15 countries, including Belgium, Greece and Poland, have demanded a cap of less than €200/MWh – far below the €275/MWh trigger limit proposed by the European Commission last month.
The Polish prime minister said the price cap would end the ability of Russia and Gazprom to distort the market.
“In the recent meetings in Brussels, our majority coalition managed to break resistance – mainly from Germany,” Mateusz Morawiecki wrote on Twitter. This means an end to market manipulation by Russia and its company, Gazprom.
($1 = 0.9419 euros)