© Reuters. Bank of Japan Governor Haruhiko Kuroda attends a press conference in Tokyo, Japan in this photo provided by Kyodo on December 20, 2022. Mandatory credit Kyodo/via Reuters
By Tom Westbrook
SINGAPORE (Reuters) – The Bank of Japan’s decision on Tuesday to adjust the scope of its policy on bond yields, a move it said was aimed at improving market performance, instead lured speculators deeper to bet on bigger changes by the developed world’s latest pigeon.
As traders were quietly backing off after a bumpy year, the Bank of Japan decided in its policy review to allow the 10-year yield to move 50 basis points either side of the 0% target, wider than the 25 basis point range previously.
It’s the largest adjustment in a six-year experiment with so-called yield curve control (YCC). But rather than providing some breathing room, investors say it is likely to encourage more of the kind of pressure that has sent the bond market out of shape.
“We didn’t trade in Japan today, which just tells you where we are. We’re happy to be short,” said Tom Nash, fixed-income portfolio manager at UBS Asset Management in Sydney, whose position is across Japan government bond futures. .
“Fifty basis points becomes a new 25 basis points. We’re just rising to that level and asking the same questions we’ve been asking before,” he said.
“Knowing that the Bank of Japan is more flexible… I think it is telling you that you should stay in these short positions.”
Governor Haruhiko Kuroda made it clear that the move was intended to smooth out market distortions, that it was “not a rate hike” and “not a revision that will lead to the abandonment of YCC or an exit from easy politics.”
However, markets, as price action signaled bets for a larger policy shift have been building steadily for months, took it as a signal that the groundwork for change was being prepared.
The Japanese yen rose sharply against the US dollar, which had been rising for weeks, in part due to growing speculation about some type of shift from the Bank of Japan, following the policy announcement, which came during the markets lunch break in Tokyo.
Upon resumption of trading in Japan, JGB 10-year yields shot towards their new ceiling and futures contracts fell so quickly that the circuit breaker stopped trading.
By the end of the session, 10-year yields were flat 14.5 basis points at 0.395%, the largest one-day rise for 10-year Japanese yields in more than 14 years.
Yields moved up across the curve as well, despite smaller increases, and interest rate swaps, which were also moving in anticipation of an eventual exit from easy policy, with 10-year swaps at a nine-year high of 87 basis points.
Those swaps – another market measure of interest rate expectations – tracked bond yields until early this year.
widow maker
Japan has become more monetary policy anomaly than ever this year as inflation has forced every other major central bank to stop buying bonds and start tightening, and it has been publicly challenged by investors.
Defending the yield target requires so much bond buying that the Bank of Japan’s holdings have exceeded half of the Japanese government bond market, according to a report released Monday.
This is the first time the figure has exceeded 50%, according to Yasunari Ueno, chief market economist at Mizuho.
As Tuesday’s turnaround brought a new promise of increased bond buying to defend its new range, market participants don’t believe it will solve jobs issues.
“This is the fundamental problem. This change is not enough,” said James Malcolm, a London-based strategist at UBS.
“YCC is now sitting on top of the economy like a bad wig, and will likely be abandoned entirely by April, if not January.”
A broader range – at least initially – could certainly allow bond trade to flow a bit more normally, while a stronger yen would take some of the heat off the economic burden that higher import costs are placing on Japanese households and manufacturers.
Heng Siang Ng, Head of Fixed Income Asia Pacific, said State Street (NYSE: Global Advisors).
But he added that it signaled the beginning of the end for Japan’s ultra-low interest rates, and possibly a bumpy ride.
“As investors assess the implications, the market may remain volatile over the coming weeks,” he said.